Bonaire vs Braemar Ducted Gas Heating

If you’re looking for a new ducted gas heating installation in Melbourne, two Australian-made brands will keep coming up in conversation: Bonaire and Braemar. Both have been warming homes across Australia for decades, both are manufactured right here on home soil, and both offer a solid range of ducted gas heaters from entry-level through to premium.

So how do you choose between them?

In this guide we’ll walk through the key differences, including star ratings, energy efficiency, zoning, controllers, warranty cover and more. Our goal is to help you make an informed decision before your next Melbourne winter rolls around.

Table of Contents

Bonaire vs Braemar Ducted Gas Heating – Models & Choices

Bonaire

Bonaire is a Climate Technologies brand that has been producing heating and cooling systems in Australia for over 60 years. Their ducted gas heating range includes five series: the MB3 (3 star), MB4 (4 star), MB5 (5 star non-condensing), MB6 (6 star) and the Rhino replacement series. Bonaire also manufactures ducted evaporative coolers and the Optima Dual Cycle add-on refrigerated air conditioning system, which pairs with their gas heaters through a shared duct system. In 2026, they now also have reverse cycle air conditioning options approved for VEU rebates.

Braemar

Braemar is a brand of Seeley International, Australia’s largest air conditioning manufacturer, and has been around since 1938. Their ducted gas heating lineup is built under the Ecostar banner and spans six tiers: 3 star, 4 star, 5 star non-condensing, 6 star and (notably) a 7 star equivalent model. They also produce the ReBuff replacement series (designed to replace other gas ducted heating models), wall furnaces, and the Dominator Series hybrid heating and cooling system for homeowners considering a transition away from gas.

They also have VEU eligible split systems, multi head splits, and ducted air conditioning options eligible for VEU rebates.

Star Ratings and Energy Efficiency of Bonaire & Braemar Ducted Gas Heaters

In Australia, the energy star rating on a ducted gas heater tells you how efficiently the unit converts gas into heat. A higher star rating means lower running costs and less energy wasted.

Bonaire tops out at a 6.0 star rating with their MB6 series. Their range covers 3.0 stars (MB3) through to 6.0 stars, with the MB5 non-condensing models sitting at 5.0–5.8 stars and the MB4 achieving between 4.0 and 4.6 stars depending on the model.

Braemar goes a step further. Their Ecostar 6 star models achieve a 6.3 star equivalent rating, and their flagship Ecostar 7 star (model TQS730) reaches a 7.0 star equivalent – making it the most energy-efficient conventional ducted gas heater on the Australian market. Braemar achieves this with Australia’s first and only inverter motor for ducted gas heating.

Our pick for energy efficiency: Braemar. The 7 star equivalent model is in a league of its own. If keeping your gas bills as low as possible is a priority, Braemar’s inverter motor technology gives it a clear edge that Bonaire’s current range can’t match.

Bonaire Ducted Gas Heater Range at a Glance

Feature Bonaire MB3 Bonaire MB4 Bonaire MB5 Bonaire MB6 Bonaire Rhino
Star Rating 3.0–3.2 4.0–4.6 5.0–5.8 6.0 3.0–5.6
Output (kW) 14–28 14–35 15–35 23–35 20–30
Zoning No Up to 4 Up to 4 Up to 4 Up to 4*
Modulating Gas Valve No Yes Yes Yes 4 & 5 star
Warranty (P&L) 3 years C5 years 5 years 5 years 5 years

*4 and 5 star Rhino models only. Zone motors supplied and installed separately.

Braemar Ducted Gas Heater Range at a Glance

Feature Braemar 3 Star Braemar 4 Star Braemar 5 Star NC Braemar 6 Star Braemar 7 Star
Star Rating 3.7 4.7 5.2 6.3 equiv. 7.0 equiv.
Output (kW) Various Various 15.9–27.8 17.9–31.2 26.6
Zoning No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Inverter Motor No No No No Yes
Warranty (Comprehensive) 7 years* 7 years* 7 years* 7 years* 7 years*

*7 year comprehensive warranty available from Seeley International participating dealers. 10 year heat exchanger and burner warranty included across all models.

Zoning and Temperature Control

Both Bonaire and Braemar offer zone control on their mid-range and premium heaters, allowing you to heat selected rooms rather than the entire house. This is one of the most effective ways to reduce your energy costs during a Melbourne winter – there’s no point pumping warm air into bedrooms when everyone’s in the living room.

Bonaire includes integrated four-zone control as standard on their MB4, MB5 and MB6 models. Each zone can have its own temperature setting when paired with multiple Navigator controllers (up to four), so different family members can set different temperatures in different parts of the home. Zone motors are supplied and installed by your air conditioning contractor at additional cost.

Braemar similarly offers zoning on their 4 star and above Ecostar models. Their MagIQtouch controller handles zone selection, and the Stealth Softair fan system adjusts airflow to deliver quieter, more comfortable operation across zones.

Our pick for zoning: It’s a tie. Both brands handle zoning well. Bonaire’s ability to run up to four independent Navigator thermostats (each with its own temperature reading) is a standout for larger homes or multi-storey layouts. Braemar’s Stealth Softair fan technology is a nice touch for noise-sensitive households.

Controllers and Smart Home Integration

The way you interact with your heating system matters, and this is an area where both brands bring something different to the table.

Bonaire offers the Navigator wall-mounted controller and the Navigator wireless RF remote. The RF remote has a built-in thermostat, which means it reads the temperature wherever you carry it – handy for two-storey homes where the ceiling temperature upstairs might be quite different from the ground floor. Bonaire also offers the optional My Climate app for Wi-Fi control via your smartphone, with compatibility for Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa voice control.

Braemar uses the MagIQtouch controller – a modern touchscreen interface that controls temperature, fan speed, zoning and programming from a sleek wall-mounted unit. It’s available in both hard-wired and RF wireless versions.

Our pick for controllers: Bonaire. The My Climate app with voice assistant compatibility gives Bonaire an edge for smart-home enthusiasts. Being able to switch on your heater from work so you walk into a warm house is a genuine quality-of-life feature during Melbourne’s colder months. That said, Braemar’s MagIQtouch screen is arguably the more polished wall-mounted unit. Keep in mind that HVAC controllers can be upgraded and retrofitted at later dates. 

Warranty Coverage

Warranty is an important consideration when you’re investing in a central heating system that will serve your home for a decade or more.

Bonaire provides a 5 year parts and labour warranty on their MB4, MB5 and MB6 series, with an optional extension to 7 years available through your dealer. The burner carries a 10 year parts warranty. The MB3 entry-level range comes with a 3 year parts and labour warranty.

Braemar offers a 7 year comprehensive warranty as standard across their entire ducted gas heating range when purchased from a Seeley International participating dealer. This also includes a 10 year heat exchanger and burner warranty. If not purchased through a participating dealer, the warranty reverts to 5 years.

Our pick for warranty: Braemar. A 7 year comprehensive warranty as standard (from participating dealers) is stronger than Bonaire’s 5 year base with optional extension. Both brands include 10 year coverage on the burner and heat exchanger, which is reassuring.

bonaire vs braemar warranty periods

Non-Condensing 5 Star Models – Tight Roof Spaces

Many Melbourne homes – particularly older weatherboard and brick veneer properties – have limited ceiling space for a ducted gas heater. Both brands offer non-condensing five star models that don’t require a condensate drain, which simplifies installation in roof cavities.

Bonaire’s MB5 non-condensing series achieves between 5.0 and 5.8 stars depending on the model, with heat outputs ranging from 15 kW to 35 kW. Braemar’s Ecostar 5 Star NC models rate at 5.2 stars across the range, with outputs from 15.9 kW to 27.8 kW. Braemar claims their non-condensing unit is 30% smaller than other five star heaters, which could be a genuine advantage in tight installations.

Our pick for compact installations: Braemar. The smaller cabinet size is a practical benefit for homes with restricted roof space. However, if you need higher heat output (up to 35 kW), Bonaire’s MB5NC-35 fills that gap.

Replacing an Old Ducted Gas Heater

If your existing ducted heater has reached the end of its life, both brands have purpose-built replacement models that make the changeover simpler and less costly.

Bonaire’s Rhino series is designed to sit on your existing air distribution base box (for externally mounted heaters), which can save on installation costs. It’s available in 3, 4 and 5 star configurations with outputs of 20 kW and 30 kW.

Braemar’s ReBuff series takes a different approach. It’s engineered to directly replace Brivis Buffalo heaters and other common brands. It comes with a gas inlet pipe matched to the existing gas supply location, available in both 3 star and 5 star models.

Our pick for replacements: It depends on your current heater. If you’re replacing a Brivis Buffalo or similar brand, the Braemar ReBuff is built for that job, or you could choose another Brivis unit. If you have an older external Bonaire unit on a base box, the Rhino is the most straightforward option.

Beyond Gas: Reverse Cycle and Future-Proofing

With Victoria’s gas substitution roadmap, it’s worth considering how each brand positions itself for the future.

Bonaire: VEU-Approved Ducted Reverse Cycle Air Conditioning

Bonaire has recently launched a new range of ducted reverse cycle high-static air conditioners, available in 10.5 kW, 12.5 kW, 14 kW and 16 kW capacities. These units are approved under Victoria’s Energy Upgrades (VEU) program with high VEECs, making them an eligible option for Melbourne homeowners looking to replace ducted gas heating with an energy-efficient electric system.

Bonaire also continues to offer the Optima Dual Cycle add-on cooling system, which pairs with their MB4, MB5 and MB6 gas heaters to provide both heating and cooling through a single duct system and controller, along with the Optima L-Series high wall split system air conditioners.

Braemar: Dominator Series 2 – A Direct Gas-to-Electric Replacement (and VEU Approved too)

Braemar’s Dominator Series 2 takes a different and arguably more targeted approach to the gas-to-electric transition. Rather than installing an entirely new ducted reverse cycle system from scratch, the Dominator Series 2 is an all-electric reverse cycle indoor unit that slots directly into the same position as your existing ducted gas heater. Your existing ductwork, ceiling vents and return air grille stay in place – the indoor unit is simply paired with a new Braemar reverse cycle outdoor unit.

This design means that in most cases there’s no need to remove the existing ductwork, no need to repair and repaint ceilings, and installation can often be completed in a single day. That’s a significant saving in both cost and disruption compared to ripping out a gas system and starting from scratch with a conventional ducted reverse cycle installation.

The Dominator Series 2 delivers 17 kW of rated heating capacity (ranging from 5.4 to 21 kW) and 13.2 kW of rated cooling capacity, all on a single phase power supply. The system can be installed internally in the ceiling, underfloor, or externally.

Braemar positions the Dominator Series 2 as compatible with any brand of ducted gas heater (including Bonaire, Brivis, Rinnai, Stadt, Lennox, Eco Pacific and Celair) making it a versatile option regardless of what’s currently in your roof. Optional zoning is available through the Braemar Zone Controller with up to 8 zones (4 RF sensors included as standard), and Wi-Fi smart app control is available with an optional Wi-Fi module. The unit comes with a 5 year manufacturer’s warranty.

Both brands also pair their gas heaters with ducted evaporative cooling systems for a year-round climate solution, which remains a popular and cost-effective combination in Melbourne’s climate. Braemar suggests that pairing the Dominator Series 2 with an existing evaporative cooler gives homeowners the most efficient heating and cooling setup – evaporative cooling for most summer days, with the reverse cycle available for the handful of humid days where evaporative technology is less effective.

Our pick for future-proofing: Both brands now offer strong options, but they suit different situations. If you’re looking for a straightforward gas-to-electric swap that reuses your existing ductwork and minimises installation disruption, the Braemar Dominator Series 2 is purpose-built for that job. 

If you’re after a VEU-approved ducted reverse cycle system with high static pressure and broader capacity options (up to 16 kW cooling), Bonaire’s new ducted AC range is well worth considering.

Running Costs and Energy Savings

The cost of running a ducted gas heater comes down to two things: how efficiently the unit converts gas into heat (star rating) and how smartly you use zoning to avoid heating empty rooms.

Bonaire estimates that upgrading from a 3 star heater to a 6 star model can save up to 30% on gas heating costs. Braemar makes a similar claim and goes further, stating that their 7 star equivalent model saves approximately $577 per year compared to a 3 star heater (based on standard testing conditions and a gas price of 1.6 cents per megajoule).

In both cases, real-world savings will depend on your home’s size and construction, ceiling height, insulation, how long you run the heating each day, your thermostat settings and local gas prices. Melbourne’s climate, with its cold winters and moderate shoulder seasons, makes energy efficiency a genuine money saver over the life of the system.

Bonaire vs Braemar Ducted Gas Heating: Which Will You Choose?

Both Bonaire and Braemar are reputable, Australian-made brands that produce reliable ducted gas heating systems. You’re in good hands with either one. That said, here’s a summary of where each brand has the edge:

Braemar presents well if: energy efficiency is your top priority (the 7 star model is unmatched), you want the strongest standard warranty coverage. You want to keep ducted gas heating, evaporative cooling, and have the option of refrigerated cooling on humid days.

Bonaire presents well if: you want smart home integration with Wi-Fi and voice control through the My Climate app, you need a combined gas heating and refrigerated cooling solution through a single duct system (Optima Dual Cycle), or you need a higher-output unit for a larger home (the MB5NC-35 delivers 35 kW at 5 star efficiency).

If you think you might want to upgrade to electric heating and cooling, both Bonaire and Braemar are approved choices for eligible VEU rebates.

Need More Help Choosing the Right System?

At ExtrordinAir, we install and service both Bonaire and Braemar ducted gas heating systems across Melbourne’s western and northern suburbs. The right heater for your home depends on your floor plan, ceiling space, insulation, budget and how you use your heating – and that’s where a professional assessment makes all the difference.

Get in touch with our team for an obligation-free quote and we’ll help you find the ducted gas heating system that’s the right fit for your home and your budget.